Week 12 · 2018

Toledo at Kent State

Thu 11/15/2018 06:00 PMDix StadiumKent State pregame21%Pregame win probability: 21% for Kent State. Toledo favored, and won.Conference

Toledo

56

7–6

Kent State

34

2–10

Attendance

5,387

reported

KENT5 plays, 52 yd · Touchdown

15:001st & 10own 35Jameson Vest kickoff for 60 yds , Jamal Parker return for 43 yds to the KntSt 48+43
15:001st & 10own 48Woody Barrett pass complete to Mike Carrigan for 9 yds to the Toled 43+9
15:002nd & 1opp 43Jo-El Shaw run for 1 yd to the Toled 42 for a 1ST down+1
15:001st & 10opp 42Woody Barrett pass complete to Mike Carrigan for 35 yds to the Toled 7 for a 1ST down+35
13:361st & goalopp 7Woody Barrett run for 7 yds for a TD (Matthew Trickett KICK)+7

TOL11 plays, 62 yd · Touchdown

13:361st & 0own 35Colten McFadden kickoff for 37 yds , Drew Rosi return for 10 yds to the Toled 38+10
13:311st & 10own 38Timeout TOLEDO, clock 13:310
13:311st & 10own 38Art Thompkins run for no gain to the Toled 380
13:312nd & 10own 38Eli Peters pass incomplete to Reggie Gilliam0
13:313rd & 10own 38Eli Peters pass complete to Art Thompkins for 11 yds to the Toled 49 for a 1ST down+11
13:311st & 10own 49Art Thompkins run for 15 yds to the KntSt 36 for a 1ST down+15
13:311st & 10opp 36Art Thompkins run for 3 yds to the KntSt 33+3
13:312nd & 7opp 33Art Thompkins run for 4 yds to the KntSt 29+4
13:313rd & 3opp 29Eli Peters pass complete to Desmond Phillips for 8 yds to the KntSt 21 for a 1ST down+8
13:311st & 10opp 21THOMPKINS, Art rush for 18 yards to the KENT3 (PARKER, JAMAL), PENALTY TOLEDO holding (ATARIWA, Yazeed) 10 yards to the KENT31, NO PLAY.−10
10:081st & 20opp 31Art Thompkins run for 31 yds for a TD (Jameson Vest KICK)+31

KENT5 plays, 6 yd · Punt

10:081st & 0own 35Jameson Vest kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback0
10:081st & 10own 25Woody Barrett pass complete to Jo-El Shaw for 2 yds to the KntSt 27+2
10:082nd & 8own 27Woody Barrett run for 4 yds to the KntSt 31+4
10:083rd & 4own 31Woody Barrett pass incomplete0
10:084th & 4own 31Derek Adams punt for 45 yds , Diontae Johnson returns for 1 yd to the Toled 32 TOLEDO Penalty, illegal block (10 Yards) declined+1

TOL10 plays, 85 yd · Touchdown

8:511st & 10own 15Bryant Koback run for 5 yds to the Toled 20+5
8:512nd & 5own 20Bryant Koback run for 51 yds to the KntSt 29 for a 1ST down+51
8:511st & 10opp 29Bryant Koback run for no gain to the KntSt 290
8:512nd & 10opp 29Eli Peters run for 5 yds to the KntSt 24+5
8:513rd & 5opp 24Bryant Koback run for 11 yds to the KntSt 13 for a 1ST down+11
8:511st & 10opp 13Bryant Koback run for 9 yds to the KntSt 4+9
8:512nd & 1opp 4Bryant Koback run for 3 yds to the KntSt 1 for a 1ST down+3
8:511st & goalopp 1Bryant Koback run for a loss of 2 yards to the KntSt 3−2
4:392nd & goalopp 3Eli Peters pass complete to Reggie Gilliam for 3 yds for a TD VEST, Jameson kick attempt good, PENALTY TOLEDO holding (BOCZAR, Andrew) 10 yards to the KENT13, NO PLAY. (Jameson Vest KICK)+3
4:391st & goalown 35VEST, Jameson kickoff 63 yards to the KENT2, PARKER, JAMAL return to the KENT18 (ANDERSON, Tycen), PENALTY TOLEDO offside (TAAFE, Tyler) 5 yards to the TOLEDO30, NO PLAY.−5

KENT8 plays, 26 yd · Punt

4:391st & 0own 30Jameson Vest kickoff for 67 yds , Jamal Parker return for 27 yds to the KntSt 30+27
4:281st & 10own 30Woody Barrett pass incomplete to Mike Carrigan0
4:282nd & 10own 30Jo-El Shaw run for 1 yd to the KntSt 31+1
4:283rd & 9own 31Woody Barrett run for 26 yds to the Toled 43 for a 1ST down+26
4:281st & 10opp 43Jo-El Shaw run for a loss of 1 yard to the Toled 44−1
4:282nd & 11opp 44Woody Barrett pass incomplete to Mike Carrigan0
4:283rd & 11opp 44Woody Barrett pass incomplete0
4:284th & 11opp 44Woody Barrett punt for 27 yds, downed at the Toled 170

TOL10 plays, 83 yd · Touchdown

2:051st & 10own 17Shakif Seymour run for 5 yds to the Toled 22+5
2:052nd & 5own 22Shakif Seymour run for a loss of 2 yards to the Toled 20−2
0:523rd & 7own 20Timeout TOLEDO, clock 00:520
0:523rd & 7own 20Eli Peters pass complete to Cody Thompson for 13 yds to the Toled 33 for a 1ST down+13
0:521st & 10own 33Shakif Seymour run for 3 yds to the Toled 36+3
0:00goal lineEnd of 1st Quarter0
15:002nd & 7own 36Eli Peters pass complete to Diontae Johnson for 16 yds to the KntSt 48 for a 1ST down+16
15:001st & 10opp 48Shakif Seymour run for 3 yds to the KntSt 45+3
15:002nd & 7opp 45Bryant Koback run for 1 yd to the KntSt 44+1
13:033rd & 6opp 44Bryant Koback run for 44 yds for a TD (Jameson Vest KICK)+44

KENT9 plays, 32 yd · Field goal

13:031st & 0own 35Jameson Vest kickoff for 59 yds , Jamal Parker return for 37 yds to the KENTST 28 TOLEDO Penalty, unsportsmanlike conduct (Jameson Vest) to the Toled 42+37
12:521st & 10opp 42Woody Barrett pass complete to Isaiah McKoy for 6 yds to the Toled 36+6
12:522nd & 4opp 36Woody Barrett run for no gain to the Toled 360
12:523rd & 4opp 36Jo-El Shaw run for 7 yds to the Toled 29 for a 1ST down+7
12:521st & 10opp 29BARRETT, WOODY pass intercepted by CLARK, Justin at the TOLEDO0, CLARK, Justin return to the TOLEDO0, PENALTY TOLEDO pass interference (CLARK, Justin) 15 yards to the TOLEDO14, 1ST DOWN KENT, NO PLAY.+15
12:521st & 10opp 14Trey Harrell run for 4 yds to the Toled 10+4
12:522nd & 6opp 10Woody Barrett pass incomplete to Isaiah McKoy, broken up by Sam Womack0
12:523rd & 6opp 10Woody Barrett pass incomplete0
11:094th & 6opp 10Matthew Trickett 27 yd FG GOOD+27

TOL5 plays, 5 yd · Punt

11:091st & 0own 35Colten McFadden kickoff for 38 yds , Drew Rosi return for 28 yds to the KntSt 45+28
11:021st & 10opp 45Art Thompkins run for 5 yds to the KntSt 40+5
11:022nd & 5opp 40Eli Peters pass incomplete to Diontae Johnson0
11:023rd & 5opp 40Art Thompkins run for no gain to the KntSt 400
11:024th & 5opp 40Bailey Flint punt for 30 yds, downed at the KntSt 100

KENT9 plays, 90 yd · Touchdown

9:371st & 10own 10Woody Barrett pass complete to Kavious Price for 6 yds to the KntSt 16+6
9:372nd & 4own 16Woody Barrett pass complete to Antwan Dixon for 20 yds to the KntSt 36 for a 1ST down+20
9:371st & 10own 36Woody Barrett pass complete to Mike Carrigan for 37 yds to the Toled 27 for a 1ST down+37
9:371st & 10opp 27Jo-El Shaw run for 6 yds to the Toled 21+6
9:372nd & 4opp 21Woody Barrett pass complete to Kavious Price for 4 yds to the Toled 17 for a 1ST down+4
8:031st & 10opp 17Timeout TOLEDO, clock 08:030
8:031st & 10opp 17Woody Barrett pass incomplete to Adam Dulka, broken up by Jordan Fisher0
8:032nd & 10opp 17Woody Barrett run for 8 yds to the Toled 9 KENT ST Penalty, Offensive holding (Isaiah McKoy) to the Toled 19−2
7:302nd & 12opp 19Woody Barrett pass complete to Isaiah McKoy for 19 yds for a TD (Matthew Trickett KICK)+19

TOL7 plays, 38 yd · On downs

7:301st & 0own 35Colten McFadden kickoff for 37 yds , Drew Rosi return for 10 yds to the Toled 38+10
7:251st & 10own 38Bryant Koback run for 5 yds to the Toled 43+5
7:252nd & 5own 43Bryant Koback run for 24 yds to the KntSt 33 for a 1ST down+24
7:251st & 10opp 33Bryant Koback run for 6 yds to the KntSt 27+6
7:252nd & 4opp 27Art Thompkins run for no gain to the KntSt 270
7:253rd & 4opp 27Eli Peters pass complete to Diontae Johnson for no gain to the KntSt 270
7:254th & 4opp 27Eli Peters pass complete to Desmond Phillips for 3 yds to the KntSt 24+3

KENT6 plays, 6 yd · Defensive TD

4:011st & 10own 24KENT ST Penalty, unsportsmanlike conduct (-12 Yards) to the KntSt 12−12
4:011st & 10own 12Woody Barrett pass complete to Antwan Dixon for 12 yds to the KntSt 24 for a 1ST down+12
4:011st & 10own 24Woody Barrett pass incomplete to Kavious Price0
4:012nd & 10own 24Woody Barrett pass complete to Kavious Price for 6 yds to the KntSt 30+6
4:013rd & 4own 30Woody Barrett pass incomplete to Kavious Price0
3:014th & 4own 30Derek Adams punt for 53 yds , Diontae Johnson returns for 83 yds for a TD (Jameson Vest KICK)+83

KENT11 plays, 30 yd · On downs

3:011st & 0own 35Jameson Vest kickoff for 60 yds , Jamal Parker return for 14 yds to the KntSt 21 Jamal Parker fumbled, forced by Victor Williams, recovered by KntSt Jo-El Shaw+14
2:561st & 10own 21Woody Barrett pass incomplete to Jo-El Shaw0
2:562nd & 10own 21BARRETT, WOODY pass complete to CARRIGAN, MIKE for 30 yards to the TOLEDO49, PENALTY KENT ineligible downfield on pass (WARNOCK, NATE) 5 yards to the KENT16, NO PLAY.−5
2:562nd & 15own 16Woody Barrett pass complete to Mike Carrigan for 12 yds to the KntSt 28+12
2:563rd & 3own 28Jo-El Shaw run for 4 yds to the KntSt 32 for a 1ST down+4
2:561st & 10own 32Woody Barrett pass complete to Antwan Dixon for 10 yds to the KntSt 42 for a 1ST down+10
2:561st & 10own 42Woody Barrett run for 3 yds to the KntSt 45+3
2:562nd & 7own 45Woody Barrett pass complete to Kavious Price for 4 yds to the KntSt 49+4
2:563rd & 3own 49Woody Barrett pass incomplete to Kavious Price, broken up by DeDarallo Blue0
1:344th & 3own 49Timeout KENT ST, clock 01:340
1:344th & 3own 49Jo-El Shaw run for 2 yds to the Toled 49+2

TOL5 plays, 16 yd · End of period

1:271st & 10own 49Shakif Seymour run for 17 yds to the KntSt 34 for a 1ST down+17
1:271st & 10opp 34Eli Peters pass incomplete to Diontae Johnson0
1:272nd & 10opp 34Shakif Seymour run for 1 yd to the KntSt 33+1
1:273rd & 9opp 33Eli Peters pass complete to Shakif Seymour for a loss of 2 yards to the KntSt 35−2
0:00goal lineEnd of 2nd Quarter0

TOL8 plays, 70 yd · Touchdown

15:004th & 11own 35Colten McFadden kickoff for 35 yds , Lucas Maynard return for no gain to the Toled 36 Lucas Maynard fumbled, recovered by Toled Lucas Maynard0
14:571st & 10own 36Eli Peters pass complete to Cody Thompson for 18 yds to the KntSt 46 for a 1ST down+18
14:571st & 10opp 46Eli Peters pass complete to Desmond Phillips for 6 yds to the KntSt 40+6
14:572nd & 4opp 40Art Thompkins run for 3 yds to the KntSt 37+3
14:573rd & 1opp 37Bryant Koback run for 7 yds to the KntSt 30 for a 1ST down+7
14:571st & 10opp 30PETERS, Eli pass incomplete to JOHNSON, Di., PENALTY KENT pass interference (HINES, ELVIS) 10 yards to the KENT20, 1ST DOWN TOLEDO, NO PLAY.+10
14:571st & 10opp 20Bryant Koback run for 5 yds to the KntSt 15+5
12:282nd & 5opp 15Bryant Koback run for 15 yds for a TD (Jameson Vest KICK)+15

KENT2 plays, 0 yd · Defensive TD

12:281st & 0own 35Jameson Vest kickoff for 61 yds , Jamal Parker return for 25 yds to the KntSt 29+25
12:131st & 10own 29Woody Barrett pass intercepted for a TD Tyler Taafe return for 31 yds for a TD (Jameson Vest KICK)−31

KENT6 plays, -1 yd · Punt

12:131st & 0own 35Jameson Vest kickoff for 63 yds , Jo-El Shaw return for 24 yds to the KntSt 26+24
12:051st & 10own 26BARRETT, WOODY pass complete to DIXON, ANTWAN for 9 yards to the KENT35 (TEACHEY, Josh), PENALTY KENT ineligible downfield on pass (WARNOCK, NATE) 5 yards to the KENT21, NO PLAY.−5
12:051st & 15own 21Woody Barrett pass incomplete0
12:052nd & 15own 21Woody Barrett run for no gain to the KntSt 210
12:053rd & 15own 21Woody Barrett pass complete to Isaiah McKoy for 4 yds to the KntSt 25+4
12:054th & 11own 25Derek Adams punt for 35 yds , Diontae Johnson returns for 5 yds to the Toled 45+5

TOL1 play, 55 yd · Touchdown

10:061st & 10own 45Eli Peters pass complete to Jon'Vea Johnson for 55 yds for a TD (Jameson Vest KICK)+55

KENT4 plays, 81 yd · Touchdown

10:061st & 0own 35Jameson Vest kickoff for 62 yds , Jamal Parker return for 16 yds to the KntSt 19+16
10:011st & 10own 19Jo-El Shaw run for 5 yds to the KntSt 24+5
10:012nd & 5own 24Woody Barrett pass incomplete to Antwan Dixon0
9:123rd & 5own 24Jo-El Shaw run for 76 yds for a TD (Matthew Trickett KICK)+76

TOL5 plays, 3 yd · Punt

9:121st & 0own 35Colten McFadden kickoff for 32 yds , Drew Rosi return for no gain to the Toled 35 Drew Rosi fumbled, recovered by Toled Drew Rosi0
9:111st & 10own 35Shakif Seymour run for 4 yds to the Toled 39+4
9:112nd & 6own 39Carter Bradley pass incomplete to Diontae Johnson0
9:113rd & 6own 39Carter Bradley run for a loss of 1 yard to the Toled 38−1
9:114th & 7own 38Bailey Flint punt for 28 yds, punt out-of-bounds at the KntSt 340

KENT13 plays, 45 yd · Field goal

7:501st & 10own 34Jo-El Shaw run for 4 yds to the KntSt 38+4
7:502nd & 6own 38Woody Barrett pass complete to Mike Carrigan for 10 yds to the Toled 48 for a 1ST down TOLEDO Penalty, personal foul (Reggie Howard) to the Toled 37 for a 1ST down+25
7:501st & 10opp 37Jo-El Shaw run for 8 yds to the Toled 29+8
7:502nd & 2opp 29KENT ST Penalty, false start (Nathan Monnin) to the Toled 34−5
7:502nd & 7opp 34Jo-El Shaw run for 2 yds to the Toled 32+2
7:503rd & 5opp 32Jo-El Shaw run for a loss of 1 yard to the Toled 33−1
7:504th & 6opp 33BARRETT, WOODY pass incomplete to PRICE, KAVIOUS, PENALTY TOLEDO pass interference (TEACHEY, Josh) 16 yards to the TOLEDO17, 1ST DOWN KENT, NO PLAY.+16
7:501st & 10opp 17Woody Barrett run for 3 yds to the Toled 14+3
7:502nd & 7opp 14Jo-El Shaw run for 6 yds to the Toled 8 for a 1ST down TOLEDO Penalty, personal foul (4 Yards) to the Toled 4 for a 1ST down+10
7:501st & goalopp 4Woody Barrett sacked by Shakif Seymour for a loss of 12 yards to the Toled 16−12
7:502nd & goalopp 16Woody Barrett pass incomplete to Kavious Price0
7:503rd & goalopp 16Jo-El Shaw run for a loss of 5 yards to the Toled 21−5
3:444th & goalopp 21Matthew Trickett 38 yd FG GOOD+38

TOL10 plays, 59 yd · Touchdown

3:441st & 0own 35Colten McFadden kickoff for 31 yds , Jamal Turner return for no gain to the Toled 41 Jamal Turner fumbled, recovered by Toled Jamal Turner0
3:421st & 10own 41Bryant Koback run for 6 yds to the Toled 47+6
3:422nd & 4own 47Bryant Koback run for 2 yds to the Toled 49+2
3:423rd & 2own 49Art Thompkins run for 9 yds to the KntSt 42 for a 1ST down+9
3:421st & 10opp 42THOMPKINS, Art rush for 4 yards to the KENT38, out-of-bounds (HICKS, DALTON), PENALTY TOLEDO holding (TURNER, Jamal) 10 yards to the TOLEDO48, NO PLAY.−10
3:421st & 20own 48Art Thompkins run for 43 yds to the KntSt 9 for a 1ST down+43
3:421st & goalopp 9Art Thompkins run for 8 yds to the KntSt 1+8
3:422nd & goalopp 1Art Thompkins run for no gain to the KntSt 10
0:00goal lineEnd of 3rd Quarter0
14:563rd & goalopp 1Art Thompkins run for 1 yd for a TD (Jameson Vest KICK)+1

KENT7 plays, 15 yd · Punt

14:561st & 0own 35Jameson Vest kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback0
14:561st & 10own 25Jo-El Shaw run for 1 yd to the KntSt 26+1
14:562nd & 9own 26BARRETT, WOODY pass incomplete to MCFADDEN, L., PENALTY TOLEDO pass interference (HOLLMAN, Kadar) 15 yards to the KENT41, 1ST DOWN KENT, NO PLAY.+15
14:561st & 10own 41Woody Barrett sacked by Jamal Hines for a loss of 3 yards to the KntSt 38−3
14:562nd & 13own 38Woody Barrett pass complete to Raekwon James for 2 yds to the KntSt 40+2
14:563rd & 11own 40Woody Barrett pass incomplete0
14:564th & 11own 40Derek Adams punt for 39 yds , Diontae Johnson returns for 17 yds to the Toled 38+17

TOL4 plays, 3 yd · Punt

12:491st & 10own 38Shakif Seymour run for 1 yd to the Toled 39+1
12:492nd & 9own 39Carter Bradley pass complete to Shakif Seymour for 2 yds to the Toled 41+2
12:493rd & 7own 41Carter Bradley pass incomplete0
12:494th & 7own 41Bailey Flint punt for 43 yds0

KENT14 plays, 84 yd · Touchdown

11:191st & 10own 16RANKIN, JUSTIN rush for 9 yards to the KENT25 (WOMACK, Samuel), PENALTY KENT holding (WARNOCK, NATE) 7 yards to the KENT9, NO PLAY.−7
11:191st & 17own 9Dustin Crum pass complete to Mike Carrigan for 5 yds to the KntSt 14+5
11:192nd & 12own 14Justin Rankin run for 2 yds to the KntSt 16+2
11:193rd & 10own 16Dustin Crum run for 19 yds to the KntSt 35 for a 1ST down+19
11:191st & 10own 35Justin Rankin run for 4 yds to the KntSt 39+4
11:192nd & 6own 39Dustin Crum pass complete to Antwan Dixon for 14 yds to the Toled 47 for a 1ST down+14
11:191st & 10opp 47Justin Rankin run for 3 yds to the Toled 44+3
11:192nd & 7opp 44Dustin Crum pass complete to Antwan Dixon for 4 yds to the Toled 40+4
11:193rd & 3opp 40Dustin Crum run for 1 yd to the Toled 39+1
11:194th & 2opp 39CRUM, Dustin pass incomplete to DIXON, ANTWAN, QB hurry by TAYLOR,Terrance, PENALTY TOLEDO roughing passer (TAYLOR,Terrance) 15 yards to the TOLEDO24, 1ST DOWN KENT, NO PLAY.+15
11:191st & 10opp 24Dustin Crum pass complete to Lon'kevious McFadden for 21 yds to the Toled 3 for a 1ST down+21
11:191st & goalopp 3Dustin Crum run for no gain to the Toled 30
11:192nd & goalopp 3Adam Dulka run for 1 yd to the Toled 2+1
6:033rd & goalopp 2Dustin Crum pass complete to Mike Carrigan for 2 yds for a TD (Matthew Trickett KICK)+2

TOL5 plays, 5 yd · Punt

6:031st & 0own 35Colten McFadden kickoff for 11 yds , Nick Kovacs return for no gain to the KntSt 460
6:021st & 10opp 46Ronnie Jones run for 5 yds to the KntSt 41+5
6:022nd & 5opp 41Ronnie Jones run for no gain to the KntSt 410
6:023rd & 5opp 41Carter Bradley pass incomplete to Desmond Phillips0
6:024th & 5opp 41Bailey Flint punt for 26 yds0

KENT5 plays, 7 yd · Punt

4:241st & 10own 15Dustin Crum sacked by Nate Givhan for a loss of 3 yards to the KntSt 12−3
4:242nd & 13own 12Dustin Crum pass complete to Trey Harrell for 10 yds to the KntSt 22+10
4:243rd & 3own 22Dustin Crum pass incomplete to Isaiah McKoy0
3:294th & 3own 22Timeout KENT ST, clock 03:290
3:294th & 3own 22Derek Adams punt for 37 yds , Desmond Phillips returns for a loss of 3 yards to the Toled 38−3

TOL6 plays, 44 yd · On downs

3:191st & 10own 38Nevone McCrimmon run for 6 yds to the KntSt 44 for a 1ST down KENT ST Penalty, face mask (15 yards) (Cepeda Phillips) to the KntSt 41 for a 1ST down+21
3:191st & 10opp 41Nevone McCrimmon run for 18 yds to the KntSt 23 for a 1ST down+18
3:191st & 10opp 23Nevone McCrimmon run for 4 yds to the KntSt 19+4
3:192nd & 6opp 19Nevone McCrimmon run for a loss of 4 yards to the KntSt 23−4
3:193rd & 10opp 23Nevone McCrimmon run for 4 yds to the KntSt 19+4
3:194th & 6opp 19Nevone McCrimmon run for 1 yd to the KntSt 18+1

KENT2 plays, 60 yd · End of period

0:051st & 10own 18Dustin Crum pass complete to Lon'kevious McFadden for 60 yds to the Toled 22 for a 1ST down+60
0:00own 0End of 4th Quarter0

Field position is from the offense’s point of view, the same as the drive chart. Play descriptions are CFBD’s own.

Previous 10 meetings vs. Team

Kent State 2–8 vs Toledo

  • 2015 · wk 6Kent State 7 @ Toledo 38
  • 2014 · wk 11Toledo 30 @ Kent State 20
  • 2010 · wk 7Kent State 21 @ Toledo 34
  • 2006 · wk 7Toledo 14 @ Kent State 40
  • 1999 · wk 7Kent State 7 @ Toledo 47
  • 1994 · wk 10Kent State 14 @ Toledo 48
  • 1993 · wk 10Toledo 45 @ Kent State 27
  • 1992 · wk 10Kent State 17 @ Toledo 32
  • 1991 · wk 10Toledo 13 @ Kent State 14
  • 1990 · wk 10Kent State 14 @ Toledo 28

Previous meeting vs. Jason Candle

Kent State 0–1 vs Jason Candle

  • 2015 · wk 6 (coaching change that season)Kent State 7 @ Toledo 38

† That school changed coaches during the season and the loader cannot say which games he took.

Research

Keep this open while you look at others