THIRD AND DATA

Week 16 · 2023

UTSA at Marshall

Tue 12/19/2023 09:00 PMToyota StadiumMarshall pregame32% — Pregame win probability: 32% for Marshall. UTSA favored, and won.Neutral site

52°Cloudy9 mph SE · 47% humidityRecorded at kickoff by College Football Data

UTSA

35

9–4

Marshall

17

6–7

Attendance

11,215

reported

Each room is drawn against the one it plays: the away offensive line beside the home defensive front, and back again. Quarterbacks, kickers and punters have no opposing room and face their own. Players are ordered exactly as they are on a team's roster tab — by position, then by who has played this season, then production, then recruiting stars, then seasons on a roster — so an offensive line, for which no production is published, runs on stars and then experience. A player who has appeared this season shows that season's totals; everyone else shows career totals through 2023, marked career, at every school he has played for. Long snappers and returners are not drawn.

UTSAQuarterbacksNo blue chips5
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB—Frank Harris6'0"·2056yr
    2,506 Pass yds18 TD8 Int64.9 Cmp%323 Rush yds
  • 33-star recruitQB2Owen McCown ← Colorado6'1"·1902yr
    442 Pass yds4 TD3 Int74.1 Cmp%51 Rush yds
  • 33-star recruitQB9Eddie Lee Marburger6'1"·2153yr
    300 Pass yds3 TD1 Int61.7 Cmp%-23 Rush yds
  • 33-star recruitQB2Jackson Gilkey6'3"·2151yr
  • 33-star recruitQB11Brandon Tennison5'10"·1901yr
MRSHQuarterbacksNo blue chips6
  • 33-star recruitQB2Cam Fancher6'0"·2073yr
    2,162 Pass yds11 TD11 Int65.6 Cmp%273 Rush yds
  • 33-star recruitQB12Cole Pennington6'4"·2202yr
    695 Pass yds0 TD6 Int57.1 Cmp%-69 Rush yds
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB13TJ McMahon5'11"·1954yr
    8 Pass yds0 TD0 Int100.0 Cmp%
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB14Colin Parachek6'3"·2152yr
    0 Pass yds0 TD1 Int0.0 Cmp%
  • 33-star recruitQB6Chase Harrison6'2"·1862yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB12Jack Schierholz6'3"·2251yr
UTSAOffensive lineNo blue chips21
MRSHDefensive line1 blue chip19
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL55Owen Porter6'3"·2375yr
    62 Tackles13.5 TFL3.5 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL11Elijah Alston6'2"·2565yr
    45 Tackles10.5 TFL5.5 Sacks1 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL—Sam Burton6'0"·2535yr
    42 Tackles7.5 TFL7.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL15Mike Green6'4"·2483yr
    41 Tackles8.0 TFL3.5 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL5TyQaze Leggs6'2"·2823yr
    40 Tackles6.5 TFL3.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL7Isaiah Gibson Sr.6'4"·3205yr
    28 Tackles2.0 TFL0.5 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL6Jalil Rivera-Harvey ← Arizona State6'3"·3002yr
    17 Tackles1.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL7Chris Thomas ← Florida6'6"·3152yr
    13 Tackles1.5 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL88Brandon McElroy6'5"·3012yr
    11 Tackles1.5 TFL0.5 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL54Kylen McCracken6'3"·3065yr
    10 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 44-star recruitDL93Jabari Ishmael6'5"·2643yr
    9 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL16Elijah Russell6'6"·2282yr
    3 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitDL43Harshan Sachdeva6'4"·2514yr
    1 Tackles1.0 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL40Joe Murray6'3"·2142yr
    1 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL90Jabarrek Hopkins6'4"·2882yr
    career 1 Tackles1.0 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL50Beni Tshita6'3"·2941yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL28Joshua Valdez-Alaniz6'4"·2711yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedDL58Braydin Ward6'6"·2581yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedDL52Mikailin Warren6'4"·3801yr
UTSADefensive lineNo blue chips16
  • —No recruiting profile foundDE33Nnanna Anyanwu6'5"·2511yr
    2 Tackles0.5 TFL0.5 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL0Jimmori Robinson6'4"·2503yr
    40 Tackles11.0 TFL4.5 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL2Brandon Brown6'2"·3204yr
    20 Tackles4.5 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL16Nick Booker-Brown6'1"·2654yr
    18 Tackles6.5 TFL2.5 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL94Joe Evans6'3"·3355yr
    18 Tackles2.5 TFL2.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL17Asyrus Simon6'4"·2554yr
    16 Tackles2.5 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL24Ronald Triplette6'2"·2603yr
    16 Tackles2.0 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL3Brandon Matterson6'2"·2956yr
    14 Tackles6.0 TFL5.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL15Trumane Bell II6'2"·2755yr
    11 Tackles3.5 TFL2.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL99Tai Leonard6'4"·2602yr
    10 Tackles2.0 TFL2.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitDL95Christian Clayton6'3"·3355yr
    10 Tackles0.5 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL98Jameian Buxton6'2"·3251yr
    2 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedDL96Travon Sylvester6'2"·2832yr
    1 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL47Tim Huff Jr.6'1"·2401yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL90Donald Quaite Jr.6'6"·3401yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL47Anthony Santoscoy6'5"·2701yr
MRSHOffensive lineNo blue chips18
UTSABacks & tight endsNo blue chips13
  • 33-star recruitRB2Kevorian Barnes5'9"·2103yr
    147 Car715 Rush yds6 TD4.9 Rush avg
    14 Rec61 Rec yds4.4 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB20Robert Henry Jr.5'9"·2051yr
    127 Car588 Rush yds11 TD4.6 Rush avg
    19 Rec115 Rec yds6.1 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB24Rocko Griffin ← Vanderbilt5'9"·2004yr
    91 Car483 Rush yds6 TD5.3 Rush avg
    9 Rec30 Rec yds3.3 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitRB17Kaedric Cobbs5'10"·2054yr
    12 Car49 Rush yds0 TD4.1 Rush avg
  • 33-star recruitRB10Brandon High Jr.5'11"·2151yr
    6 Car14 Rush yds0 TD2.3 Rush avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB21Justin Rodriguez5'7"·1804yr
    career 16 Car38 Rush yds1 TD2.4 Rush avg
    3 Rec13 Rec yds4.3 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB39Ethan Laing5'10"·2002yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB42Mason Culton5'7"·1901yr
  • 33-star recruitTE84Oscar Cardenas6'4"·2655yr
    32 Rec280 Rec yds2 TD8.8 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitTE87Houston Thomas6'5"·2522yr
    9 Rec101 Rec yds0 TD11.2 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitTE5Dan Dishman6'6"·2454yr
    3 Rec30 Rec yds0 TD10.0 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitTE9Patrick Overmyer6'5"·2401yr
  • 33-star recruitTE45Devin Scura6'6"·2601yr
MRSHLinebackers1 blue chip14
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB24Eli Neal6'0"·2265yr
    93 Tackles11.0 TFL2.5 Sacks2 Int
  • 44-star recruitLB14Stephen Dix Jr.6'1"·2404yr
    62 Tackles7.0 TFL2.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB44KeSean Brown ← App State6'1"·2215yr
    35 Tackles3.0 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB22Kerion Martin6'1"·2204yr
    31 Tackles2.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB25J'Coryan Anderson6'2"·2335yr
    29 Tackles1.5 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB1Jaden Yates6'1"·2251yr
    6 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB7Tah Mac Bright Banda6'2"·2353yr
    5 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB15Landyn Watson ← TCU6'1"·2453yr
    4 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB6Leon Hart Jr.6'0"·2152yr
    career 1 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB41Jayven Hall6'0"·2121yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB37Jackson Marshall6'2"·2292yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedLB13Mathis Haygood6'4"·2301yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB7Ryan Sissel6'2"·2251yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB7Marc Viechec5'11"·2201yr
UTSALinebackersNo blue chips20
  • 33-star recruitLB0Jamal Ligon6'2"·2354yr
    62 Tackles7.0 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB37Martavius French6'2"·2252yr
    61 Tackles4.5 TFL1.5 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitLB7Donyai Taylor6'1"·2104yr
    47 Tackles7.0 TFL2.0 Sacks1 Int
  • 33-star recruitLB10Avery Morris6'2"·2254yr
    45 Tackles3.0 TFL2.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB8Trey Moore6'3"·2493yr
    45 Tackles17.5 TFL14.0 Sacks1 Int
  • 33-star recruitLB2Owen Pewee6'3"·2202yr
    30 Tackles6.5 TFL1.0 Sacks1 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB22Rodney Groce Jr.6'0"·2203yr
    12 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB3Kaleb Brown6'1"·2312yr
    7 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB26Bryce Grays ← Washington State6'1"·2052yr
    6 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB39Kyle Wakefield6'0"·1954yr
    6 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB41Daron Allman ← Angelo State6'1"·2301yr
    4 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB31Vic Shaw6'3"·2401yr
    2 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB1Camron Cooper6'2"·2452yr
    1 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB34James Walley Jr.6'2"·2501yr
    1 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB36Jaylon Lott6'0"·2204yr
  • 33-star recruitLB13Corey Lucius6'2"·2081yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB45Mason Hall5'10"·2202yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB16Chris Bryson II6'2"·1951yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB53Darrius Govan6'3"·2101yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB55Amare Johnson6'2"·2201yr
MRSHBacks & tight endsNo blue chips18
  • 22-star recruitRB22Rasheen Ali6'0"·2094yr
    212 Car1,140 Rush yds15 TD5.4 Rush avg
    28 Rec213 Rec yds7.6 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB28Ethan Payne6'0"·2113yr
    83 Car335 Rush yds1 TD4.0 Rush avg
    16 Rec117 Rec yds7.3 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitRB2A.J. Turner6'0"·2002yr
    6 Car20 Rush yds0 TD3.3 Rush avg
    1 Rec5 Rec yds5.0 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB44Antwan Roberts Jr.6'0"·2001yr
    2 Car11 Rush yds0 TD5.5 Rush avg
    1 Rec17 Rec yds17.0 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitRB27Maurice Jones5'7"·1852yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB6DeMarcus McElroy5'9"·1952yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB10Randy Young5'10"·2001yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB29C.J. Fazio5'9"·2001yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE15Cade Conley ← Central Michigan6'4"·2322yr
    23 Rec215 Rec yds1 TD9.3 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitTE83Sean Sallis6'4"·2402yr
    5 Rec51 Rec yds1 TD10.2 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE86Chris Mottillo6'5"·2552yr
    4 Rec43 Rec yds0 TD10.8 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE80Luke Soto6'5"·2504yr
    1 Rec8 Rec yds0 TD8.0 Rec avg
  • 22-star recruitTE81Toby Payne6'4"·2372yr
    career 2 Rec27 Rec yds1 TD13.5 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE88Rahmod Smith6'5"·2405yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedTE85Beau Blankenship6'4"·2452yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE19Marcus Velez6'6"·2502yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedTE80Shawn Rouse6'3"·2441yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedTE85Tracy Stephens6'4"·2421yr
UTSAReceiversNo blue chips14
  • 22-star recruitWR2Joshua Cephus6'3"·1855yr
    89 Rec1,151 Rec yds10 TD12.9 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR11Tykee Ogle-Kellogg6'5"·2256yr
    33 Rec575 Rec yds7 TD17.4 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR3Devin McCuin6'0"·1951yr
    42 Rec546 Rec yds3 TD13.0 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR19Willie McCoy III6'0"·1851yr
    18 Rec164 Rec yds2 TD9.1 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR0David Amador II6'0"·1951yr
    11 Rec102 Rec yds1 TD9.3 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR5Chris Carpenter5'11"·1604yr
    7 Rec52 Rec yds0 TD7.4 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR10Jace Wilson6'4"·2122yr
    2 Rec26 Rec yds0 TD13.0 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR11Jaren Randle6'2"·1804yr
    2 Rec15 Rec yds0 TD7.5 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR1De'Corian Clark6'3"·2205yr
    career 112 Rec1,559 Rec yds16 TD13.9 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR13Jamel Hardy Jr.6'3"·1901yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedWR29Kyle Eaves5'9"·1504yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR23Grayson Medford5'9"·1652yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR85Chu-Chu Doe5'11"·2001yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR83Ezekiel Saldana5'9"·1851yr
MRSHDefensive backs3 blue chips24
  • 33-star recruitCB35D'Yoni Hill6'0"·1802yr
    54 Tackles10 PD1 Int
  • 44-star recruitCB1Josh Moten6'0"·1854yr
    30 Tackles6 PD1 Int
  • 33-star recruitCB10Jacobie Henderson5'11"·1982yr
    24 Tackles4 PD
  • 44-star recruitCB8Ishmael Ibraheem6'0"·1782yr
    6 Tackles0 PD
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedCB20TaShawn Jeter6'1"·1771yr
    1 Tackles0 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundCB18Sean Reese6'0"·1902yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundCB29Jason Haggerty5'10"·1731yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDB11J.J. Roberts ← Wake Forest5'11"·1844yr
    74 Tackles1 PD2 Int
  • 33-star recruitDB6Micah Abraham5'11"·1855yr
    36 Tackles15 PD4 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundDB29Ishmael Roy5'11"·1862yr
    6 Tackles0 PD
  • 44-star recruitDB4Jadarius Green-McKnight5'11"·1984yr
    2 Tackles0 PD
  • 33-star recruitDB6Myles Bell ← UConn6'0"·1804yr
    1 Tackles0 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundDB29Caleb Horton6'0"·1882yr
    career 2 Tackles0 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundDB31Joshua McTier5'11"·1712yr
    career 1 Tackles0 PD
  • 33-star recruitDB0Caleb Clark-Glover5'11"·1871yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDB7CJ Davis5'10"·1951yr
  • 33-star recruitS6AG McGhee5'10"·1872yr
    48 Tackles3 PD1 Int
  • 33-star recruitS5Ahmere Foster5'10"·1731yr
    28 Tackles2 PD1 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundS23Jahsen Wint6'0"·2004yr
    14 Tackles0 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundS17Daytione Smith6'0"·1904yr
    11 Tackles1 PD
  • 33-star recruitS12Gabriel Grubbs6'0"·1922yr
    career 2 Tackles0 PD
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedS0Ian Foster5'10"·1811yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundS39Mason Mitchell5'6"·1771yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundS19Jacob Pinkney5'11"·1841yr
UTSADefensive backsNo blue chips19
  • 33-star recruitCB4Nicktroy Fortune6'0"·1905yr
    26 Tackles9 PD2 Int
  • 33-star recruitCB23Dywan Griffin5'11"·1705yr
    26 Tackles4 PD1 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundCB13Syrus Dumas ← New Mexico State5'10"·1803yr
    5 Tackles1 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundCB11Zah Frazier6'3"·1852yr
    3 Tackles1 PD
  • 33-star recruitCB4Davin Martin6'2"·1851yr
    2 Tackles0 PD
  • 33-star recruitCB23Xavier Spencer6'0"·2004yr
    1 Tackles0 PD
  • 33-star recruitCB27Jakevian Rodgers6'1"·1651yr
    1 Tackles0 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundCB10Alpha Khan6'1"·1752yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDB18Kam Alexander5'11"·1752yr
    34 Tackles15 PD2 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundDB31Pig Cage5'9"·2003yr
    6 Tackles1 PD
  • 33-star recruitDB15Cinque Williams5'10"·1873yr
    career 1 Tackles0 PD
  • 33-star recruitS4Ken Robinson5'11"·1905yr
    65 Tackles4 PD
  • 33-star recruitS—Rashad Wisdom5'9"·2105yr
    61 Tackles4 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundS29Elliott Davison ← Incarnate Word6'0"·1902yr
    40 Tackles1 PD2 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundS6Kelechi Nwachuku6'0"·2055yr
    37 Tackles1 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundS12Marcellus Wilkerson6'1"·2101yr
    15 Tackles1 PD
  • 33-star recruitS28Je'Vaun Dabon6'1"·1904yr
    2 Tackles0 PD
  • 33-star recruitS24Jalen Rainey6'5"·2052yr
    career 1 Tackles0 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundS37Ronald Link-Milam Jr.6'2"·2001yr
MRSHReceiversNo blue chips16
  • 33-star recruitWR2Jayden Harrison5'10"·1985yr
    28 Rec410 Rec yds1 TD14.6 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR4DeMarcus Harris6'1"·1785yr
    24 Rec396 Rec yds1 TD16.5 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR16Caleb Coombs5'11"·1873yr
    39 Rec310 Rec yds2 TD7.9 Rec avg
  • 22-star recruitWR5Caleb McMillan6'1"·2005yr
    18 Rec275 Rec yds2 TD15.3 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR3Chuck Montgomery5'10"·1802yr
    20 Rec269 Rec yds3 TD13.5 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR6Darryle Simmons6'3"·2115yr
    25 Rec262 Rec yds0 TD10.5 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR3Mason Pierce5'6"·1633yr
    16 Rec171 Rec yds0 TD10.7 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR1Talik Keaton6'0"·1905yr
    14 Rec143 Rec yds0 TD10.2 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR3Bryan Robinson6'1"·2004yr
    5 Rec35 Rec yds0 TD7.0 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR0Cam Pedro5'11"·1802yr
  • 33-star recruitWR84Antwaan Mays6'2"·1981yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR84Antonio Robinson6'3"·1852yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedWR82Gerald Campbell6'0"·1751yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR18Justin Haggerty5'9"·1691yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR41Logan Howell5'5"·2071yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR16K.J. Jones5'10"·1851yr
UTSAKickersNo blue chips3
  • 22-star recruitPK29Tate Sandell5'9"·1782yr
    1 FG2 FGA47 Long5 Pts
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK82Chase Allen6'1"·2164yr
    13 FG15 FGA53 Long88 Pts
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK92Michael Petro5'10"·1801yr
MRSHKickersNo blue chips3
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedPK90Rece Verhoff5'11"·2152yr
    11 FG18 FGA44 Long65 Pts
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK99Kameron Lake6'2"·1891yr
    1 FG2 FGA20 Long7 Pts
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK97Marco Peery5'10"·1651yr
UTSAPuntersNo blue chips1
  • 33-star recruitP5Lucas Dean6'2"·2155yr
    51 Punts42.3 Avg20 In 20
MRSHPuntersNo blue chips5
  • 22-star recruitP19John McConnell6'3"·1903yr
    55 Punts43.1 Avg13 In 20
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedP38Alec Clark6'0"·1861yr
    7 Punts40.3 Avg1 In 20
  • —No recruiting profile foundP49Drew Petit5'9"·2021yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundP43Will Petit6'2"·1981yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedP95Nathan Totten6'1"·2301yr

Previous 3 meetings vs. UTSA

Marshall 2–1 vs UTSA

  • 2018 · wk 12UTSA 0 @ Marshall 23
  • 2017 · wk 12Marshall 7 @ UTSA 9
  • 2013 · wk 6UTSA 10 @ Marshall 34

Research

Keep this open while you look at others