Honors

ColgateRaiders

6 consensus All-Americans between 1913 and 1930 · 3 national awards.

All-Americans

1913–1930

Heisman

no winners

Consensus All-Americans

Season	Player	Pos
1930	Leonard Macaluso	B
1919	D. Belford West	T
1916	Clarence Horning	T
1916	D. Belford West	T
1916	Oscar Anderson	B
1913	Ellery Huntington	B

National awards

Wins only. Places in the voting are listed separately below.

Award	Won
Walter Payton Player of the Year Award	2
Ernie Davis Award	1

Every winner

Season	Award	Player
2004	Ernie Davis Award	Jamaal Branch RB
2003	Walter Payton Player of the Year Award	Jamaal Branch RB
1987	Walter Payton Player of the Year Award	Kenny Gamble RB

Source: the NCAA’s official Football Records and Awards books, 2026 edition — printed there as COLGATE. Consensus All-America is the NCAA’s own designation, recognising players named by a majority of the official selectors in a given season.