Honors

DartmouthBig Green

17 consensus All-Americans between 1903 and 1938, 1 unanimous · 1 national award.

All-Americans

1903–1938 · 1 unanimous

Heisman

no winners

Consensus All-Americans

Season	Player	Pos
1938	Bob MacLeod	B
1925	Andy Oberlander unanimous	B
1925	Carl Diehl	G
1925	George Tully	E
1924	Carl Diehl	G
1919	Adolph Youngstrom	G
1917	Eugene Neely	G
1915	Clarence Spears	G
1914	Clarence Spears	G
1913	Robert Hogsett	E
1912	Wesley Englehorn	T
1908	Clark Tobin	G
1908	George Schildmiller	E
1905	Ralph Glaze	E
1904	Joseph Gilman	G
1903	Henry Hooper	C
1903	Myron Witham	B

National awards

Wins only. Places in the voting are listed separately below.

Award	Won
Mayo Clinic Comeback Player of the Year	1

Every winner

Season	Award	Player
2018	Mayo Clinic Comeback Player of the Year	Seth Simmer DT (FCS)

Award voting — other places

Second through fourth in the voting. Never counted as wins.

Season	Award	Player	Place	Points
1938	Heisman Memorial Trophy	Bob MacLeod	4th	78

Source: the NCAA’s official Football Records and Awards books, 2026 edition — printed there as DARTMOUTH. Consensus All-America is the NCAA’s own designation, recognising players named by a majority of the official selectors in a given season.