Honors

PrincetonTigers

65 consensus All-Americans between 1889 and 1965, 1 unanimous · 2 national awards.

All-Americans

1889–1965 · 1 unanimous

Heisman

1951

Consensus All-Americans

Season	Player	Pos
1965	Stas Maliszewski	G
1952	Frank McPhee	E
1951	Dick Kazmaier unanimous	B
1935	John Weller	G
1925	Ed McMillan	C
1922	C. Herbert Treat	T
1921	Stan Keck	G
1920	Donold Lourie	B
1920	Stan Keck	T
1918	Frank Murrey	B
1916	Frank Hogg	G
1914	Harold Ballin	T
1913	Harold Ballin	T
1912	John Logan	G
1911	Edward Hart	T
1911	Joseph Duff	G
1911	Sanford White	E
1910	Talbot Pendleton	B
1908	Frederick Tibbott	B
1907	Edwin Harlan	B
1907	James McCormick	B
1907	L. Casper Wister	E
1906	Edward Dillon	B
1906	James Cooney	T
1906	L. Casper Wister	E
1905	James McCormick	B
1904	James Cooney	T
1903	Howard Henry	E
1903	J. Dana Kafer	B
1903	John DeWitt	G
1902	John DeWitt	G
1901	Ralph Davis	E
1899	Arthur Hillebrand	T
1899	Arthur Poe	E
1899	Howard Reiter	B
1898	Arthur Hillebrand	T
1898	Lew Palmer	E
1897	Addison Kelly	B
1897	Garrett Cochran	E
1896	Addison Kelly	B
1896	John Baird	B
1896	Robert Gailey	C
1896	William Church	T
1895	Dudley Riggs	G
1895	Langdon Lea	T
1894	Arthur Wheeler	G
1894	Langdon Lea	T
1893	Arthur Wheeler	G
1893	Franklin Morse	B
1893	Langdon Lea	T
1893	Philip King	B
1893	Thomas Trenchard	E
1892	Arthur Wheeler	G
1892	Philip King	B
1891	Jesse Riggs	G
1891	Philip King	B
1891	Sheppard Homans	B
1890	Jesse Riggs	G
1890	Ralph Warren	E
1890	Sheppard Homans	B
1889	Edgar Allan Poe	B
1889	Hector Cowan	T
1889	Knowlton Ames	B
1889	Roscoe Channing	B
1889	William George	C

National awards

Wins only. Places in the voting are listed separately below.

Award	Won
Heisman Memorial Trophy	1
Maxwell Award	1

Every winner

Season	Award	Player
1951	Maxwell Award	Dick Kazmaier HB
1951	Heisman Memorial Trophy	Dick Kazmaier HB

Award voting — other places

Second through fourth in the voting. Never counted as wins.

Season	Award	Player	Place	Points
1935	Heisman Memorial Trophy	Pepper Constable	4th	20

Source: the NCAA’s official Football Records and Awards books, 2026 edition — printed there as PRINCETON. Consensus All-America is the NCAA’s own designation, recognising players named by a majority of the official selectors in a given season.