THIRD AND DATA

Week 9 · 2019

San José State at Army

Sat 10/26/2019 12:00 PMMichie StadiumArmy pregame74% — Pregame win probability: 74% for Army. Army favored, and lost — San José State won.

San José State

34

5–7

Army

29

5–8

Attendance

35,346

reported

Each room is drawn against the one it plays: the away offensive line beside the home defensive front, and back again. Quarterbacks, kickers and punters have no opposing room and face their own. Players are ordered exactly as they are on a team's roster tab — by position, then by who has played this season, then production, then recruiting stars, then seasons on a roster — so an offensive line, for which no production is published, runs on stars and then experience. A player who has appeared this season shows that season's totals; everyone else shows career totals through 2019, marked career, at every school he has played for. Long snappers and returners are not drawn.

SJSUQuarterbacksNo blue chips4
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB12Josh Love6'2"·2054yr
    3,923 Pass yds22 TD7 Int61.0 Cmp%-88 Rush yds
  • 33-star recruitQB16Alec Trujillo5'11"·1701yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB14Jake Simmons6'1"·2052yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB14Matt Der Torossian6'3"·1951yr
ARMYQuarterbacksNo blue chips10
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB8Kelvin Hopkins Jr.5'10"·2054yr
    577 Pass yds4 TD6 Int42.9 Cmp%718 Rush yds
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB1Jabari Laws5'9"·1852yr
    311 Pass yds1 TD0 Int80.0 Cmp%484 Rush yds
  • 33-star recruitQB4Christian Anderson6'1"·1953yr
    135 Pass yds1 TD0 Int30.4 Cmp%429 Rush yds
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB7Jemel Jones5'10"·2001yr
    43 Pass yds0 TD1 Int75.0 Cmp%42 Rush yds
  • 22-star recruitQB18Cade Ballard5'9"·2001yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB15Clay Czyzynski6'0"·2002yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB2Tyhier Tyler5'8"·1832yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB11Walter Harris6'1"·2241yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundQB5Steven Migut6'0"·1851yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedQB38Kyle Terry6'0"·1811yr
SJSUOffensive lineNo blue chips17
ARMYDefensive lineNo blue chips21
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL55Edriece Patterson6'3"·2553yr
    37 Tackles5.0 TFL3.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL57Jacob Covington6'2"·2604yr
    36 Tackles4.5 TFL1.5 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL97Kwabena Bonsu6'4"·2862yr
    33 Tackles6.0 TFL2.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL93Rod Stoddard5'11"·2804yr
    14 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitDL18Jake Ellington6'3"·2404yr
    11 Tackles0.5 TFL0.5 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL95Nolan Cockrill6'3"·2802yr
    6 Tackles1.5 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedDL94Nick Stokes6'5"·3003yr
    3 Tackles0.5 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL91Ryan Duran III6'5"·2702yr
    2 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL44Nathaniel Smith6'3"·2651yr
    2 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL99Chris Frey6'5"·2651yr
    1 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL90Jack Hough6'3"·2803yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL93Rod Stoddard5'11"·2802yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL75Ryan Bryce6'5"·2641yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL92Reed Chandler6'3"·2341yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL60David Gray6'4"·3001yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL94Conor Hough6'2"·2181yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL59Henry Janeway6'4"·2451yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL93Tyler Komorowski6'3"·2851yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL72Kenese Leomiti6'4"·2931yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL96Darius Richardson6'2"·2951yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL93Cody Winokur6'2"·2771yr
SJSUDefensive lineNo blue chips17
  • —No recruiting profile foundDE95Cameron Alexander6'5"·3003yr
    5 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDE42Viliami Fehoko6'4"·2331yr
    4 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDL42Viliami Fehoko6'4"·2632yr
    44 Tackles3.0 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitDL92Cade Hall6'3"·2702yr
    39 Tackles8.0 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitDL97Christian Johnson6'6"·2763yr
    19 Tackles1.5 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitDL54Demanuel Talauati6'1"·3052yr
    14 Tackles4.0 TFL2.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL99Dimitri Sakalia6'3"·2681yr
    2 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitDL94Jamaar Hardy6'3"·2733yr
    career 5 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL93Sinjun Astani6'4"·2704yr
    career 3 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL91E.J. Ane6'2"2yr
    career 3 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL96Duane Tuitasi6'1"·2994yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL90Lando Grey6'2"·2903yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL48Josh Gomez6'2"·2651yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDL69Kyane Schmidt6'3"·2281yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDT4Sailosi Latu6'3"·3344yr
    54 Tackles2.5 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitDT91EJ Ane6'2"·2752yr
    32 Tackles5.0 TFL2.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundDT98Terrell Townsend6'4"·2684yr
    2 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
ARMYOffensive lineNo blue chips31
SJSUBacks & tight endsNo blue chips15
  • 33-star recruitFB44Beaux Tagaloa6'0"·2501yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB21DeJon Packer5'11"·2244yr
    126 Car567 Rush yds11 TD4.5 Rush avg
    27 Rec270 Rec yds10.0 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB32Kairee Robinson5'7"·1891yr
    40 Car174 Rush yds0 TD4.4 Rush avg
    7 Rec51 Rec yds7.3 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitRB23Tyler Nevens6'0"·2253yr
    42 Car145 Rush yds1 TD3.5 Rush avg
    3 Rec15 Rec yds5.0 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB36Hunter Nye5'11"·2053yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB33Brendan Manigo5'10"·1972yr
  • 33-star recruitRB29Adi Anderson5'10"·2011yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB38Romero Teu5'9"·1903yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE85Brett Foley6'3"·2364yr
    17 Rec195 Rec yds1 TD11.5 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE87Derrick Deese Jr.6'4"·2353yr
    19 Rec179 Rec yds2 TD9.4 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE81Billy Bob Humphreys6'5"·2453yr
    15 Rec130 Rec yds1 TD8.7 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE30Jackson Burrill6'2"·2453yr
  • 33-star recruitTE81Dominick Mazotti6'4"·2231yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE87Derrick Deese, Jr.6'4"·2352yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE49Noah Sanchez6'2"·2151yr
ARMYLinebackersNo blue chips25
  • 22-star recruitLB54Cole Christiansen6'2"·2254yr
    112 Tackles3.5 TFL2.5 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB53Arik Smith6'0"·2402yr
    83 Tackles4.0 TFL2.5 Sacks
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedLB2Malkelm Morrison5'10"·1902yr
    44 Tackles3.0 TFL0.5 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitLB43Jeremiah Lowery6'2"·2553yr
    42 Tackles4.0 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB11Donavan Lynch6'0"·2154yr
    25 Tackles3.0 TFL1.5 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB52Amadeo West6'2"·2454yr
    13 Tackles0.5 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB15Ryan Parker6'0"·2304yr
    11 Tackles0.5 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitLB31Joe Stephenson6'0"·2353yr
    10 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitLB34Jack King6'2"·2154yr
    6 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitLB47Jon Rhattigan6'1"·2453yr
    6 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB38Fabrice Voyne6'2"·2201yr
    5 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB49Kemonte Yow6'1"·2402yr
    4 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB47Jarrod Jones5'10"·2104yr
    2 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitLB44Gavin Bassett6'1"·2154yr
    career 7 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB18Cole Mabry6'2"·2051yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB36Nate Jones6'2"·2152yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB56DeLani Carter5'11"·2211yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedLB34Andre Carter II6'7"·2601yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB48Trevor Cosenke6'3"·2331yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB36Peyton Hampton6'1"·2251yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB30Cameron Hoelscher6'2"·2351yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB38Brandon Mays6'0"·2241yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB30Daryan McDonald6'0"·2151yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB19Troy Nachtigal5'10"·2261yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB50JT Penick6'3"·2401yr
SJSULinebackersNo blue chips17
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB31Ethan Aguayo6'2"·2204yr
    102 Tackles3.5 TFL2.0 Sacks1 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB45Kyle Harmon6'0"·2252yr
    89 Tackles6.0 TFL2.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB11Jesse Osuna6'0"·2254yr
    64 Tackles7.0 TFL3.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB—Tysyn Parker6'1"·2373yr
    52 Tackles3.5 TFL1.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitLB16Rico Tolefree6'1"·2333yr
    50 Tackles2.5 TFL2.0 Sacks2 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB41Hadari Darden6'3"·2073yr
    30 Tackles1.5 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB46Christian Webb6'3"·2354yr
    18 Tackles1.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 22-star recruitLB8Jordan Cobbs6'1"·2351yr
    9 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • 33-star recruitLB40Isa'ako Togia6'1"·2072yr
    2 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedLB8Alii Matau6'1"·2263yr
    career 25 Tackles2.0 TFL0.0 Sacks1 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB37Isaiah Ossai5'9"·2103yr
    career 7 Tackles0.5 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB59Lionell Wiggins6'3"·2385yr
    career 4 Tackles0.0 TFL0.0 Sacks
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB53Cameron Hanson6'2"·2303yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB51Devon Calloway6'0"·2172yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB35Lorenzo Burkes6'2"·2301yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB49Michael Pryor6'3"·2271yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundLB40Isa'ako Togia6'1"·2071yr
ARMYBacks & tight endsNo blue chips32
  • —No recruiting profile foundFB42Wilson Catoe6'2"·2402yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB25Connor Slomka6'0"·2404yr
    148 Car650 Rush yds7 TD4.4 Rush avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB3Sandon McCoy5'11"·2303yr
    134 Car576 Rush yds10 TD4.3 Rush avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB5Kell Walker5'9"·1954yr
    58 Car398 Rush yds3 TD6.9 Rush avg
    4 Rec41 Rec yds10.3 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB32Artice Hobbs IV5'9"·1903yr
    28 Car158 Rush yds2 TD5.6 Rush avg
    13 Rec335 Rec yds25.8 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitRB40Cade Barnard6'3"·2352yr
    18 Car95 Rush yds2 TD5.3 Rush avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB33Jakobi Buchanan6'0"·2501yr
    19 Car88 Rush yds0 TD4.6 Rush avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB16Malik Hancock5'8"·1704yr
    10 Car75 Rush yds1 TD7.5 Rush avg
    2 Rec46 Rec yds23.0 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitRB23Anthony Adkins6'2"·2451yr
    9 Car36 Rush yds1 TD4.0 Rush avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB34Rashaad Bolton5'11"·2354yr
    10 Car32 Rush yds1 TD3.2 Rush avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB5A.J. Howard6'0"·2052yr
    2 Car28 Rush yds0 TD14.0 Rush avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB48Kaelin Byrd5'11"·2052yr
    3 Car14 Rush yds0 TD4.7 Rush avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB11Brandon Walters5'11"·1852yr
    4 Car1 Rush yds0 TD0.3 Rush avg
    4 Rec96 Rec yds24.0 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB21Zack Boobas5'10"·1804yr
    career 2 Car23 Rush yds1 TD11.5 Rush avg
    1 Rec14 Rec yds14.0 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB19Dominic Distefano5'9"·1905yr
    career 1 Car10 Rush yds0 TD10.0 Rush avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB32Artice Hobbs IV5'9"·1753yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB30Ton Evans5'8"·1852yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB25Markens Pierre5'11"·2052yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB31Trey Bartlett5'9"·1851yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB23Adam Bazan5'10"·1891yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedRB9Maurice Bellan5'10"·1851yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB46Colton Dooley5'11"·2001yr
  • —Recruiting profile found — unratedRB28Justin Lescouflair5'10"·1901yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB8Braheam Murphy5'10"·1821yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB37Ridge Polk5'9"·1671yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundRB39Noah West6'3"·2251yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE83Zach Saum6'5"·2505yr
    career 1 Rec9 Rec yds0 TD9.0 Rec avg
  • 22-star recruitTE30Cole Truex6'2"·2401yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE81Jake Lauer6'3"·2653yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE39Bryton Belvin6'7"·2302yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE85Chris Cameron6'4"·2602yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundTE85Eddie Crutchfield6'3"·2252yr
SJSUReceiversNo blue chips17
  • 33-star recruitWR10Tre Walker5'11"·1803yr
    79 Rec1,161 Rec yds2 TD14.7 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR84Bailey Gaither6'1"·1824yr
    52 Rec812 Rec yds6 TD15.6 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR9Isaiah Hamilton5'11"·1871yr
    43 Rec718 Rec yds4 TD16.7 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR11JaQuan Blackwell6'0"·1983yr
    15 Rec183 Rec yds1 TD12.2 Rec avg
  • 22-star recruitWR84Isaiah Holiness5'10"·1831yr
    15 Rec145 Rec yds1 TD9.7 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR9Andre Crump Jr.6'0"·1801yr
    6 Rec118 Rec yds1 TD19.7 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR13Jermaine Braddock6'1"·1911yr
    6 Rec75 Rec yds2 TD12.5 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR3Nick Nash6'3"·1951yr
    1 Rec4 Rec yds0 TD4.0 Rec avg
  • 22-star recruitWR17Sitaleki Nunn5'11"·1822yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR26Austin Liles6'3"·1944yr
    career 10 Rec98 Rec yds0 TD9.8 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR12Malikhi Miller6'4"·2111yr
  • 33-star recruitWR21Jamar Simpson5'11"·1611yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR86Vincent Corso5'10"·1723yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR41Steven Houston6'4"·1972yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR8Chance La Chapelle6'4"·2251yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR17Sitaleki Nunn5'11"·1821yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR83Isac Velasquez5'11"·1811yr
ARMYDefensive backsNo blue chips25
SJSUDefensive backsNo blue chips17
  • —No recruiting profile foundCB23Nehemiah Shelton6'2"·1852yr
    42 Tackles7 PD3 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundCB12Brandon Ezell6'0"·1824yr
    36 Tackles4 PD4 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundCB2Zamore Zigler5'10"·1704yr
    27 Tackles3 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundCB25Charlie Bostic III5'11"·1951yr
    1 Tackles0 PD
  • 33-star recruitCB38Stan Livingstone6'0"·1751yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundCB6Johnny Balderas6'1"·1872yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundDB5Bobby Brown II6'0"·1803yr
    24 Tackles1 PD3 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundDB20Tre White6'0"·1892yr
    5 Tackles0 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundS27Jay Lenard6'1"·2074yr
    95 Tackles3 PD2 Int
  • —No recruiting profile foundS3Tre Webb6'0"·2023yr
    58 Tackles0 PD1 Int
  • 33-star recruitS22Tre Jenkins5'11"·2192yr
    7 Tackles0 PD
  • 33-star recruitS27Andrew Jenkins5'9"·1872yr
    3 Tackles0 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundS1Chandler Hawkins5'11"·2064yr
    3 Tackles0 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundS34Jalend Dinwiddie5'11"·1863yr
    career 1 Tackles0 PD
  • —No recruiting profile foundS14Bobby Brown, II6'0"·1802yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundS19B.J. Johnson6'2"·2001yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundS27Jay Lenard6'1"·2071yr
ARMYReceiversNo blue chips17
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR88Camden Harrison6'2"·2083yr
    25 Rec433 Rec yds3 TD17.3 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR14Michael Roberts6'3"·2352yr
    3 Rec32 Rec yds0 TD10.7 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR82Kjetil Cline6'0"·2054yr
    4 Rec23 Rec yds0 TD5.8 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR86Christian Hayes6'0"·2004yr
    1 Rec17 Rec yds0 TD17.0 Rec avg
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR89Jalen Moy6'4"·2102yr
  • 22-star recruitWR6Glen Coates6'0"·1955yr
    career 9 Rec136 Rec yds0 TD15.1 Rec avg
  • 33-star recruitWR85Trenton Waggoner6'0"·1841yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR80Chris Gregg6'0"·1904yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR10Jordan Blackman5'11"·1903yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR87Sean Eckert6'3"·2202yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR84Kevin Hamilton6'1"·1882yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR5Cole Caterbone6'1"·2001yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR82Veshe Daniyan6'1"·1971yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR83Reikan Donaldson6'2"·1901yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR85Trenton Hollinquest6'0"·1841yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR80Ryan Jackovic6'5"·2251yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundWR31Cole Wright6'3"·2051yr
SJSUKickersNo blue chips4
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK48Chris Wood5'11"·1852yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK39Matthew Mercurio6'1"·1751yr
    20 FG24 FGA49 Long97 Pts
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK39Matt Mercurio6'1"·1761yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK38Collin Tamas5'10"·1871yr
ARMYKickersNo blue chips7
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK45David Cooper6'2"·1854yr
    3 FG4 FGA40 Long33 Pts
    1 Punts40.0 Avg0 In 20
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK1Landon Salyers6'1"·2003yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK99Andrew Bagley5'11"·1901yr
    0 FG0 FGA0 Long1 Pts
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK94Cole Talley6'0"·2051yr
    1 FG3 FGA41 Long22 Pts
  • 22-star recruitPK6Michael Leisle6'0"·1853yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK98Matteo Cordray5'9"·1701yr
  • —No recruiting profile foundPK27Will Van Pamelen6'0"·2041yr
SJSUPuntersNo blue chips1
  • —No recruiting profile foundP43Alex Galland6'2"·2094yr
    47 Punts39.7 Avg4 In 20
ARMYPuntersNo blue chips3
  • —No recruiting profile foundP17Zach Potter5'10"·2004yr
    0 FG0 FGA0 Long0 Pts
    16 Punts40.5 Avg2 In 20
  • —No recruiting profile foundP46Zach Harding6'5"·2202yr
    20 Punts48.6 Avg3 In 20
  • —No recruiting profile foundP37Brooks Hosea6'0"·1852yr

Previous meeting vs. San José State

Army 1–0 vs San José State

  • 2018 · wk 7Army 52 @ San José State 3

Previous meeting vs. Jeff Monken

San José State 0–1 vs Jeff Monken

  • 2018 · wk 7Army 52 @ San José State 3

Previous meeting vs. Brent Brennan

Army 1–0 vs Brent Brennan

  • 2018 · wk 7Army 52 @ San José State 3

Research

Keep this open while you look at others